Motion New Trial

Draft Post-Verdict Motions for New Trial in Minutes

12 minutes with CaseMark

Run this workflow

Run it in CaseMark

Upload your documents and get a finished work product in minutes. New accounts get $5 free to run their first skill.

12 minutes with CaseMark

What you'll need

Trial Transcripts
Verdict and Case Information
Jury Instructions

SOC 2 Type II · HIPAA compliant · $5 free credit

Workflow

Overview

CaseMark's Motion for New Trial skill automates the drafting of post-verdict motions in criminal defense cases, transforming trial transcripts and record materials into structured, citation-rich legal arguments. The AI identifies supported grounds, maps facts to legal standards, and produces a court-ready motion complete with anticipatory rebuttals and a comprehensive prayer for relief.

Drafting a Motion for New Trial requires painstaking review of trial transcripts, identification of every viable ground for relief, and meticulous record citation for each argument. Criminal defense attorneys often spend days combing through hundreds of transcript pages, cross-referencing jury instructions, and researching controlling authority—all under tight post-verdict filing deadlines.

CaseMark automates the heavy lifting of post-verdict motion drafting by analyzing your trial transcripts, identifying supported grounds, and generating a structured motion with precise record citations and controlling legal authority. The result is a comprehensive, court-ready Motion for New Trial that would have taken days to draft manually, completed in minutes with full attorney oversight.

How it works

1. Upload trial transcripts, verdict details, jury instructions, and any post-trial materials
2. AI identifies supported grounds and extracts key record citations
3. Review the structured motion with ground-by-ground arguments and legal authority
4. Export the finalized motion in your preferred format (DOCX, PDF)

What you get

Caption & Header
Introduction with Procedural Authority and Thesis
Grounds for New Trial (Weight-of-Evidence, Newly Discovered Evidence, Prosecutorial Misconduct, Juror Misconduct, IAC, Judicial Error)
Per-Ground Factual Basis with Record Citations
Per-Ground Legal Standard and Controlling Authority
Per-Ground Application and Prejudice Analysis
Anticipatory Rebuttal Sections
Memorandum of Law
Prayer for Relief

What it handles

Ground-by-ground argument structuring with record citations
Automatic legal standard mapping for each asserted ground
Prejudice and harmless-error analysis for every claim
Jurisdiction-formatted caption and procedural authority references
Anticipatory rebuttal drafting for waiver and procedural default
Comprehensive prayer for relief with evidentiary hearing requests

Required documents

Trial Transcripts
Complete or relevant portions of trial transcripts with page and line numbers for key testimony, rulings, and objections
.pdf, .docx
Verdict and Case Information
Verdict date, charges of conviction, case number, court name, and defendant information
.pdf, .docx
Jury Instructions
Jury instructions as given by the court, including any refused defense instructions
.pdf, .docx

Supporting documents

Post-Trial Materials
Newly discovered evidence, affidavits, expert reports, or other post-trial materials supporting grounds for relief
.pdf, .docx
Trial Exhibit List
Numbered list of trial exhibits admitted or offered into evidence
.pdf, .docx
Applicable Rules and Local Requirements
Fed. R. Crim. P. 33 or state equivalent, along with any local court rules governing new trial motions
.pdf, .docx

Why teams use it

Reduce motion drafting time from days to minutes while maintaining rigorous legal standards

Ensure no viable ground for relief is overlooked with systematic record analysis

Strengthen each argument with automatic prejudice analysis and harmless-error rebuttals

Produce consistently formatted, jurisdiction-appropriate motions with accurate record citations

Questions

What grounds for new trial does CaseMark support?

CaseMark structures arguments around all recognized grounds including weight-of-evidence, newly discovered evidence, prosecutorial misconduct, juror misconduct, ineffective assistance of counsel, and judicial error. The AI only asserts grounds that are supported by the uploaded record materials.

Does the motion include proper record citations?

Yes. CaseMark extracts and inserts specific transcript page and line citations, exhibit numbers, and quoted rulings throughout each ground. Every factual assertion is tied back to the trial record you provide.

Can I use this for both federal and state new trial motions?

Absolutely. CaseMark drafts under Fed. R. Crim. P. 33 or your state's equivalent rule. Simply indicate your jurisdiction and applicable procedural rule, and the AI will format the motion accordingly.

How does CaseMark handle harmless error and waiver arguments?

Each ground includes an anticipatory rebuttal section that proactively addresses harmless error, waiver, and procedural default arguments the prosecution is likely to raise, strengthening your motion before it's filed.

How long does it take to generate a Motion for New Trial?

CaseMark typically generates a comprehensive, multi-ground Motion for New Trial in approximately 10-15 minutes, depending on the volume of trial transcripts and the number of supported grounds identified.

Can I customize which grounds are included in the final motion?

Yes. After CaseMark identifies supported grounds from your record, you can review, add, remove, or reorder grounds before finalizing. You maintain full control over the motion's content and strategy.