Motion New Trial

Draft Criminal New Trial Motions in Minutes, Not Hours

14 minutes with CaseMark

Run this workflow

Run it in CaseMark

Upload your documents and get a finished work product in minutes. New accounts get $5 free to run their first skill.

14 minutes with CaseMark

What you'll need

Trial Transcripts
Verdict and Case Information
Jury Instructions

SOC 2 Type II · HIPAA compliant · $5 free credit

Workflow

Overview

CaseMark's Motion for New Trial skill transforms trial transcripts, verdict details, and jury instructions into a comprehensive, court-ready post-verdict motion. The AI identifies viable grounds from the record, structures each argument with proper legal standards and transcript citations, and anticipates prosecution rebuttals—delivering a polished motion that would otherwise take hours of manual drafting.

Drafting a Motion for New Trial is one of the most demanding tasks in criminal defense. Attorneys must comb through lengthy trial transcripts, identify every viable ground, map facts to exacting legal standards, and anticipate prosecution counterarguments—all under tight post-verdict filing deadlines that leave little room for error.

CaseMark automates the heavy lifting by analyzing your trial record, identifying supported grounds, and drafting each section with proper citations, controlling authority, and prejudice analysis. The result is a structured, comprehensive motion that meets professional standards and frees defense counsel to focus on strategy and client advocacy.

How it works

1. Upload trial transcripts, verdict details, jury instructions, and any post-trial materials
2. AI identifies supported grounds and maps record citations to each legal standard
3. Review the structured motion with ground-by-ground arguments and anticipatory rebuttals
4. Export the court-ready motion in your preferred format (DOCX, PDF)

What you get

Caption & Header
Introduction with Procedural Authority and Thesis
Grounds for New Trial (Weight of Evidence, Newly Discovered Evidence, Prosecutorial Misconduct, Juror Misconduct, IAC, Judicial Error)
Legal Memorandum with Case Authority
Prayer for Relief

What it handles

Ground-by-ground argument structuring with record citations
Automatic legal standard mapping for each asserted ground
Prejudice and harmless-error analysis for every claim
Transcript page-and-line citation integration
Anticipatory rebuttal drafting for waiver and procedural default
Court-ready formatting with caption, memorandum, and prayer for relief

Required documents

Trial Transcripts
Complete or relevant portions of trial transcripts with page and line numbers for key testimony, rulings, and objections
.pdf, .docx
Verdict and Case Information
Verdict date, charges of conviction, case number, court name, and defendant information
.pdf, .docx
Jury Instructions
Jury instructions as given by the court, including any refused defense instructions
.pdf, .docx

Supporting documents

Exhibit List
Numbered list of trial exhibits admitted or offered into evidence
.pdf, .docx
Post-Trial Materials
Newly discovered evidence, witness affidavits, expert reports, or other post-trial materials supporting the motion
.pdf, .docx
Applicable Rule or Statute
Text of Fed. R. Crim. P. 33 or the applicable state rule governing motions for new trial
.pdf, .docx

Why teams use it

Dramatically reduce drafting time on complex post-verdict motions while maintaining thoroughness

Ensure no viable ground for relief is overlooked with systematic record analysis

Strengthen each argument with built-in prejudice analysis and anticipatory rebuttal sections

Produce consistently formatted, citation-rich motions ready for court filing

Questions

What grounds for new trial does CaseMark support?

CaseMark analyzes your record for all recognized grounds including weight-of-evidence challenges, newly discovered evidence, prosecutorial misconduct, juror misconduct, ineffective assistance of counsel, and judicial error. It only asserts grounds that your uploaded record actually supports.

Does the motion include proper transcript citations?

Yes. CaseMark integrates page-and-line citations from your uploaded trial transcripts directly into each factual basis section, so every argument is anchored to the record.

Can I use this for both federal and state new trial motions?

Absolutely. CaseMark drafts under Fed. R. Crim. P. 33 or your state's equivalent rule. Simply specify the applicable jurisdiction and rule, and the motion will conform to the correct procedural authority.

How does CaseMark handle harmless error and waiver arguments?

Each ground includes an anticipatory rebuttal section that proactively addresses harmless error, waiver, and procedural default arguments the prosecution is likely to raise, strengthening your motion before it's filed.

Can I add newly discovered evidence or post-trial affidavits?

Yes. You can upload post-trial materials such as newly discovered evidence, expert reports, and witness affidavits. CaseMark will incorporate them into the appropriate ground with the required legal showing.

How long does it take to generate a complete motion?

CaseMark typically generates a fully structured Motion for New Trial in approximately 14 minutes, compared to the many hours required for manual drafting and research.